I know you, my fair readers, just buy tartar sauce when you need it. Who doesn’t? At first I thought that tartar sauce fell into the same category as ketchup and mustard – that being the category of things that even though I’m an obsessed home chef, I still buy these items prepared at the store. I don’t, for example, churn my own butter, nor do I have a cow that I milk in the mornings. My children have recently been lobbying for chickens, live ones, in the yard, in West LA. This is a losing battle on their part. I am not going to agree to chickens. I did decide to follow the advice of my father and try making my own tartar sauce. This is his recipe. It goes well with all kinds of shellfish. I like it best on shrimp, but it’s a multi-tasker – this recipe.
- 2 cups mayonnaise
- 2 small boiled potatoes, cold, peeled and mashed (1.5 inch diameter red potatoes)
- 2 teaspoons parsley, minced
- 1 teaspoon capers, finely chopped
- 2 tablespoons of dill pickle, finely chopped
- ⅛th teaspoon freshly ground white pepper
- ¼ teaspoon salt
Thoroughly combine all ingredients and chill for two hours before serving.
The sauce may be thinned with lemon juice if it is too thick.



















{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }
Tartar sauce has potatoes in it? Who knew!
I doubt that all tartar sauce has potatoes in it. My Dad’s does – and it is super yummy. Try it!!
You mention it goes well with shell fish-how about a really good piece of baked fish/homemade fish sticks, grilled fish etc.
Sylvia – OF COURSE it goes with fish sticks!
Alexander just caught a ten pound halibut and he will be needing a great tartar sauce recipe! Thank you
If Alexander has a ten pound halibut he better be ready to share some!
I like tartar sauce made with mayo, chow chow, capers, and fresh onion.
I had no idea about the potatoes…but it sounds delic. Thanks for th tip.